Who is Josh From 90 Day Dating? Latest on Josh Weinstein

Hey there, 90 Day Fiancé fan! If you’re like me, you’ve been glued to the rollercoaster that is Josh Weinstein’s love life. Between the on-and-off drama with Natalie Mordovtseva and the swirling rumors about Jenn Potthast, it’s tough to keep up.

You’re probably curious about Josh’s current dating status, frustrated by outdated gossip, and eager for trustworthy details on his romantic journey. Well, buckle up—I’m diving into the latest on Josh from 90 Day Fiancé, and I promise to keep it clear, current, and packed with personality!

Josh Weinstein sparked dating rumors with 90 Day Fiancé star Jenn Potthast earlier this year, and fans have been buzzing ever since. After his messy split from Natalie, you’d think he’d take a breather, but nope—Josh is back in the dating game, and it’s got everyone talking. Let’s break it down, sort fact from fiction, and figure out who’s really stealing his heart in 2025.

Who Is Josh Weinstein Anyway?

Josh isn’t your average reality TV guy. He’s the smooth-talking CEO of Preview Models, a gig that puts him in the spotlight with aspiring stars like Natalie. He popped onto 90 Day Fiancé: The Single Life Season 2 as Natalie’s new love interest after she ditched Mike Youngquist.

Josh has been dating Natalie on and off for a little over three years, a saga that’s had more twists than a soap opera. With two kids from past relationships and a life split between Arizona and LA, he’s juggling a lot—yet still finds time to stir up drama on 90Days.

His vibe? Think laid-back businessman with a knack for keeping us guessing. He’s not married—never has been, as far as we know.

Who Is Josh from 90 Day Fiancé Dating Now?

Josh dropped a bombshell on The Sarah Fraser Show podcast in February 2025, saying he’s “seeing someone from the 90 Day universe.” Cue the fan frenzy! Theories flew faster than a reality TV breakup, and one name kept popping up: Jenn Potthast.

Josh Weinstein was recently caught up in dating rumors with Jenn Potthast, sister to 90 Day star Elizabeth “Libby” Potthast. In March 2025, he posted an Instagram Story of them sipping drinks together, tagging Jenn Potthast Instagram handle and all. Fans went wild—Josh Weinstein and Jenn Potthast? Could it be true? Libby Potthast’s sister Jenn isn’t a main cast member, but she’s popped up enough to count as “90 Day universe” material. Plus, Josh knows the Potthast family through Libby’s mom, who runs a casting agency. It’s a cozy connection.

But hold up—there’s a twist. Days later, a blogger snapped pics of Josh at the Las Vegas airport with a mystery blonde. She wasn’t Jenn, and she didn’t look like any known 90 Day face. S

Josh loves teasing us, and he’s hinted his new girl will show up at The Last Resort Season 2 Tell All, airing on March 31, 2025. Host Shaun Robinson even teased, “Some of you might recognize her.” My gut says it’s not Jenn—or anyone we expect.

Is Josh Still with Natalie?

Josh confirmed that he and Natalie are no longer dating. That’s right—after three years of breakups and makeups, their rocky road hit a dead end on 90 Day: The Last Resort Season 2, which aired late 2024. The couple split for good during the commitment ceremony, with Natalie wishing Josh happiness as they parted ways. It was a tearjerker, but not a shocker. Natalie wanted a ring and a baby.

Their history is a wild ride. Natalie moved to California for Josh, banking on his modeling connections to kickstart her Hollywood dreams. But he never fully committed—wouldn’t even call her his girlfriend! She leaned on him for cash, a car, and an apartment, yet he kept her at arm’s length. Tensions boiled over when Natalie found out Josh was messaging Sophie Sierra about a Vegas trip. She accused him of cheating, and the trust was toast.

Now, Natalie’s hinting at a new guy with the initials “JS” on Instagram—think roses and fancy golf club dates.

What About Calie Tagle?

Josh was linked to a woman named Calie Tagle, and this rumor’s got legs—or maybe a whole house in Scottsdale. Word on the street (and some old Instagram screenshots) says Josh and Calie, a Preview Models coworker, have been a thing for over five years. Allegedly, they’ve lived together while Josh filmed with Natalie.

If true, Natalie might’ve been a side hustle for TV fame. But here’s the kicker: no recent pics or posts tie Josh to Calie in 2025. Did they split? Is she the airport blonde? It’s a puzzle missing half the pieces.

Jenn Potthast: The Rumored Flame

Let’s zoom in on Jenn Potthast and Josh. She’s Libby’s older sister, a Florida gal with a flirty vibe and a history of 90 Day cameos. Josh Weinstein sparked dating rumors with 90 Day Fiancé star Jenn Potthast back in 2023, when they filmed a playful restaurant video together.

Natalie was still in the picture then, so folks brushed it off as friendly banter. Fast forward to March 2025, and that Instagram Story reignited the spark. They follow each other on Jenn Potthast Instagram, and their chemistry screams more than “just friends.”

But Jenn’s not confirmed it. Neither has Josh. His ex-wife, Candice, once told a mag they were pals, not lovers. Still, the 90 Day crowd’s convinced—Jenn Potthast and Josh could be the next big couple. Or it’s all a smokescreen for that Tell All reveal. I’m leaning toward the latter; Josh loves a good plot twist.

Other 90 Day Suspects

Josh’s “90 Day universe” clue opened the floodgates. She’s single now, but there’s zero evidence. How about Kimberly or Kim from The Other Way? Nope, they’re off the radar. Jasmine? Too busy with Gino.

Fans even tossed out Vanja Grbic and Kara Rojer as options. Vanja laughed it off in a Q&A; Kara teased it with a winking emoji. Neither fits the airport blonde’s profile. Josh is playing us like a fiddle, and I’m here for it.

Josh’s Romantic Journey: A Recap

Josh’s love life is a maze. He met Natalie at a modeling gig, swept her off her feet with promises of LA glitz, then left her hanging. Before that, he fathered kids with two different women—neither named, neither dramas we’ve seen. Post-Natalie, he’s dodged commitment like a pro. The Calie rumors hint at a double life; the Jenn buzz suggests a franchise fling. Now, he’s got a new girl ready to step into the Tell All spotlight.

What’s next? If she’s a cast member, we might see Josh on The Single Life again. If she’s an outsider, he could fade from 90Days. Either way, his charm keeps us hooked.

The Tell All Tease

Tonight’s Tell All is the moment of truth. Josh’s new girl steps out, and I’ll bet my last dollar it’s not who we think. Jenn Potthast might be a decoy; Calie Tagle could be ancient history. My wild guess? A fringe player from the franchise—like a friend of a friend we’ve glimpsed once. Josh loves a curveball, and 90 Day thrives on chaos.

Conclusion

We’re hours away from knowing. Josh Weinstein and Jenn Potthast might be the hot rumor, but that airport blonde’s got me second-guessing. Natalie’s out, a new chapter’s in, and Josh is living his best 90 Day life. Stick around for the Tell All—it’s gonna be a doozy!